Sign in or
"An ideology is a complex system of values, ideas, pictures, images, and perceptions that motivate men and women to see their particular place in the social order as natural, inevitable, and necessary (Gayle Yee)."
All texts, as well as readers, carry conscious and unconscious ideologies. These ideologies, or worldviews, work actively to conform, or naturalize, the text or reader to her/his ideology. For example, a Biblical text can't help but present a certain worldview based on its historical and social context. Furthermore, the very act of writing implies that something was spurring the author to write; therefore, we can assume an agenda, or a persuasive element, at work in the writing. Thus we must be aware the text that we read is actively attempting to reshape our own ideology to its own, to convince us that its worldview and argument are natural, universal and self-evidently correct.
Unfortunately, ancient texts often represent only the ideologies of those with access to educated scribes and the time and means to produce texts. Since those texts are presenting their ideologies as universally held, we must also seek to uncover, perhaps 'between the lines,' or in other comparable texts, the voices of those marginalized. Since the text presents an argument, we can also reconstruct the opposing side of the issue.
Intrinsic and Extrinsic Aspects of Ideological Criticism
Social Scientific Criticism (Extrinsic) - Historical criticism that seeks to understand ancient socioeconomic institutions and relationships in order to better understand the text.
Examples: setting and function, practices of a certain tribe, archaeological evidence, contemporaneous writings from the Levant and Mesopotamia
New Literary (Rhetoric) Criticism (Intrinsic) - Influenced by literary marxism, this approach contends that a text "produces" readers by shaping their views into the ideology of the text. The literary text elements at hand work together to try to persuade, inform, influence, and entertain the reader in order to have the reader assent to the writer's worldview, touch the reader's heart, and seize the attention of the reader. (eg. myth or narrative) structures.
Latest page update: made by me_lisa
, Oct 31 2009, 7:02 AM EDT
(about this update
About This Update
Edited by me_lisa
10 words added
1 word deleted
- complete history)
More Info: links to this page
|Started By||Thread Subject||Replies||Last Post|
|BrookeLester||Basic claim of IC||0||Oct 20 2009, 1:31 AM EDT by BrookeLester|
Thread started: Oct 20 2009, 1:31 AM EDT Watch
Nice start, I see a definition of ideology, and a word on the *tools* use by IC for its extrinsic and intrinsic tasks.
But what of its basic claim or insight about texts: that they (on the one hand) reflect the ideology/ies from which they arise (there's that social scientific task for the exegete), and that they (on the other hand) seek to reproduce that/those ideology/ies in the reader (there's that New Literary task). Make sense? This is the insight or conviction that makes an ideological critic want to get out of bed in the morning and do ideological criticism.
Showing 1 of 1 threads for this page